Hi everyone,
Although Public Mobile may not support 5G any time soon, I thought I would start writing about what's new with this latest technology. There's a lot of terminology and confusion, so hopefully this will help!
You may have heard the terms NSA, SA, NR, DSS, mmWave, network slicing, and many other buzzwords. But what does it all mean?
To start, let's get some definitions out of the way.
NR = New Radio, this is the 5G wireless standard (equivalent to LTE for 4G)
eNodeB (eNB) = 4G base station
gNodeB (gNB) = 5G base station
NSA = Non-standalone, a type of 5G connection requires 4G at the same time in order to operate
SA = Standalone, a type of 5G connection has no dependency on 4G
At a high level, there are 3 broad categories for 5G, and the technology is expected to support these use cases:
1) eMBB: enhanced mobile broadband
2) mMTC: massive machine-type communications
3) URLLC: ultra reliable low-latency communications
Let's talk about each in a bit more detail.
eMBB is what we're all using today. It's smartphones and other devices that support extremely high speeds and capacity for things like high speed data, fixed wireless broadband (wireless home internet), virtual or augmented reality (VR/AR). This is supported with 5G NSA and 5G SA.
mMTC will come later. It will support massive deployment of IoT devices, which basically means sensors and smart devices everywhere. Think millions of devices needing very little data. This will be supported only on 5G SA.
URLLC is also a future technology. Its goal is sub 1ms latency and extremely high reliability for mission-critical applications like factory automation, remote controlled vehicles, remote surgery, etc. It's important to note that URLLC can't support high Gbps throughput. This will be supported only on 5G SA.
Ok, let's talk about the differences between SA and NSA. Basically it comes down to 2 things. SA needs a new 5G core network, while NSA can use the old 4G EPC core network, but it must also use 4G eNB at the same time.
When 5G was first being developed as a concept, researchers came up with 7 different network options:
eNB connected to EPC (4G core) --> this is the existing LTE network
gNB connected to 5GC (5G core) --> this is the final stage of the 5G Standalone (SA) network
NSA EN-DC: eNB and gNB connected to EPC (LTE is anchor)
NSA NE-DC: eNB and gNB connected to 5GC (NR is anchor) --> not going to be deployed
eNB connected to 5GC --> not going to be deployed
gNB connected to EPC --> not going to be deployed
NSA NGEN-DC: eNB and gNB connected to 5GC (LTE is anchor) --> not going to be deployed
Here is a visual representation of all the options, courtesy of GSMA:
You can see 3 possibilities for NSA. Operators and vendors settled on Option 3x (a variant of Option 3) since it didn't require a new 5G core network. This allowed the industry to rapidly deploy 5G NSA while using existing 4G core networks.
You may have heard the term LTE anchor, or anchor band. In the context of 5G NSA, all of the signaling between the network and phone is done on LTE. In order for 5G NSA to work, the phone must first find a suitable LTE band to act as an "anchor", and then wait for the network to add 5G on top for extra speed. It also means if a 5G NSA phone only has 5G coverage (no LTE), it won't work. It'll be completely out of service. Finally, voice calls on 5G NSA are done entirely on LTE with VoLTE.
Only Option 2 and Option 3x are actually adopted and deployed by the industry for 5G.
The deployment of a brand new 5G Core for SA is extremely complex and requires considerable effort and resources. This is the main reason why 5G NSA was introduced.
With 5G NSA, there can be many bands on the LTE side and NR side. For example, an operator can deploy 32 CA LTE + 16 CA NR in principle, but they would need to have lots of spectrum, RAN software that supports it, and most importantly a phone that supports that specific combo in order to use it. Bell/Telus are currently deploying 2-7-7-66_n78_n78. They have 4 LTE + 2 NR bands aggregated as their main combo. They can add more combos on their network, but without a phone that can use those combos, it's pointless.
5G band numbers start with lower-case "n", to differentiate from LTE. For example, Telus can deploy LTE band 66, or NR band n66. It's the same spectrum. An operator can choose to deploy their spectrum as LTE or NR as they wish.
A new concept in 5G is DSS or Dynamic Spectrum Sharing. This allows an operator to deploy a frequency band as 4G and 5G simultaneously. The eNB and gNB will dynamically schedule traffic to users depending on the demand. There is quite a bit of overhead and inefficiency associated with DSS (especially on the 5G side), so it is not used for small channels like 5 or 10 MHz. Typically it is used for 15 or 20 MHz.
Let's talk about peak speeds (or eMBB). With a combo like 2-7-7-66_n78_n78, there is 75 MHz of LTE and 80 MHz of 5G (GTA spectrum). This can get close to 3 Gbps technically, but a realistic speed test would yield something like 1-2 Gbps in good conditions. If Bell and Telus launched SA, they would only have n78-n78. They can't use the LTE bands at the same time in an SA scenario. Which means, peak speeds on SA will be slower than NSA, at least for a few years until phone manufacturers stop supporting new NSA combos. Eventually NSA will stop being developed and everyone will work to make SA better. At some point in the next few years, we will see SA speeds catch up to NSA.
As for latency, there is a small improvement with 5G compared to LTE in general, even with 5G NSA. This can bring real-world latency down to low double digits, with the eventual promise of low latency coming with URLLC. This technology promises latencies of less than 1ms, but it will not be a simple achievement. There are going to be many years of small, incremental improvements until we see latencies in the low single digits.
From what I've seen so far, networks cannot support high throughput and sub-ms latency on the same device. The tradeoffs needed to achieve low latency will result in lower throughput. I believe smartphones will be designed for peak speeds, and may get to 5ms latency, but not sub-ms. New applications will require sub-ms latency on specialized 5G equipment, which will be achieved by trading throughput for better latency and reliability. URLLC is only possible with SA.
Another important concept that will be introduced with 5G SA is Network Slicing. This is the concept of the network giving specific resources and profiles to user applications, similar to what I described above with eMBB, mMTC and URLLC. Here's a good picture, again courtesy of GSMA:
Lastly, let's talk about spectrum. All existing LTE bands can be used for 5G. Some bands that are overlapping are no longer defined. For example, in LTE we have B17 and B12, where B12 is a superset. In 5G we only have n12. Same idea for B4 and B66, in 5G we only have n66.
Alright, so now we know operators can repurpose or "re-farm" their existing spectrum for 5G when they are ready. They can also use DSS to do a soft re-farm of 4G and 5G on wider channels like 15 or 20 MHz.
In the initial 5G specifications, 3GPP defined traditional frequencies as "Frequency Range 1", also known as FR1. This was spectrum up to 6000 MHz, which is why people started referring to it as sub-6 or sub 6 GHz. The specs were later modified and FR1 now goes up to 7125 MHz, although sub-6 is a term that is still used. A new frequency range known as FR2 has been adopted, operating in much higher frequencies.
FR2 frequencies have wavelengths generally less than 1cm. For this reason, FR2 is commonly referred to as millimeter wave or mmWave.
As always, if you have more questions, just ask and I will be happy to try to answer them!
Previous topics are still available here: https://productioncommunity.publicmobile.ca/t5/Get-Support/LTE-network-fundamentals/td-p/130581
5G Topic #1: What does the 5G icon mean?
For such a simple question, it's a pretty complicated answer due to the way 5G NSA operates.
Phone manufacturers have implemented different strategies for displaying the 5G icon. 4 configurations were proposed by the industry, while only "Config A" and "Config D" were implemented. In Canada, most phones including iPhones are using "Config D".
A "Config D" phone will only show LTE icon when the LTE cell isn't configured to support 5G NSA (i.e. the LTE cell cannot act as an anchor band). For all other LTE cells that are capable of acting as an anchor band, the "Config D" phone will always show a 5G icon. This is the case even if there is zero 5G coverage. The phone determines the network status by looking for upperLayerIndication-r15 information element in SIB2 of the LTE cell.
Here is a brief description of what each row is referring to:
- Phone is idle or connected (active), camping on LTE cell that is not an NSA anchor (i.e. pure LTE)
- Idle or connected (active) to an LTE cell that is a real NSA anchor, but there is no 5G coverage at this location
- Connected (active) to an LTE cell that is a real NSA anchor, there is 5G coverage at this location, BUT the 5G part isn't active right now (only LTE is being used by the phone)
- Same as #3, but phone is idle (camping on LTE)
- Actually using 5G NSA (both LTE and NR are active simultaneously)
- Idle or connected to 5G SA cell (no LTE)
"Config A" is the honest implementation, it only shows 5G when 5G is used.
"Config D" will show 5G strictly based on LTE network configuration. It's more dishonest than Config A.
Samsung has chosen to implement 2 different icons for Config D software. When a Config D phone is not using 5G, the background will be white (left picture below), but when 5G is active it will be dark (right picture below).
Starting in 2023, Canadian operators have asked phone manufacturers to display 5G+ icon when n78 is being used, as this is expected to significantly increase speeds.
