cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Android One; secure, fast, and always up to date!

GTB86
Good Citizen / Bon Citoyen

Has anyone heard of Android One!?

 

It gets regular security updates and software updates right away. There are no skins and extra stuff added in by the phone manufacturers, it's just the stock android that comes straight from Google. 

Here is a low cost phone that has been praised by critics that you can get on Amazon.

 

I wanted to share this product from Amazon.ca with you
https://www.amazon.ca/gp/aw/d/B076HQ6FSY

24 REPLIES 24

hopeyb
Great Neighbour / Super Voisin

Might be a plug, but I will say I'm pretty stoked with my phone. I love the idea of buying a quality phone outright and not working about a $1000 debt over my shoulder. I will update based on how it goes. 🙂 Setup was easy with public mobile. The sim card took me a few minutes, but I'm old so...

killer23d
Great Citizen / Super Citoyen

@zhadj030 wrote:

@killer23d wrote:

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.


I rather get I really paid for then pay for an overpriced 1K smartphones despite the fact that it should only cost half of that price in a perfect world. Chinese phones are making a huge breakthrough in Europe and the rest of the world except North America the only  2 reasons they are not as popular and an option in North America is lack of full bands support and Lobbying.

Regarding Warranties, they are a nightmare no matter the name of the company, (I am not even going to mention Samsung/ LG because of how annoying their warranty departement is) 

About the info being "leaked", it is the same as in the US. You cannot tell me that your info are not with NSA or other agencies just because you have an Apple or a Samsung product. No product is fully secure no matter what.


It is always a value proposition and what is your comfort level. I had a fair share of experience with Xiaomi and LeEco and the phone is almost a throw-away when it needs service. The costs to send back is just not economical. At the very least you can talk/chat with someone on LG, Samsung and even ZTE if you need service. It could be a nightmere (never in my case), but it's at least possible. Samsung and LG have service center in Richmond, so I always drop the phones off.

 

Chinese phone makers have been caught multiple times embedding tracking/adware/malware into their firmware. I have yet to recall similar numbers of reports on other manufacturers. I just don't want to be in that statistic.

 

You are correct that some phones are overpriced, but I would counter-argue that the costs could be justified. I had a ZTE Axon 7 which is very good and cheap ($450 for flagship), but service sucks, battery died in 6 months and I waited a month to get my phone swapped from Toronto. On the other hand, I paid full price for the Pixel 2 XL, my camera lens has some dust inside, Google replaced the phone in 2 days. There are just a lot of intangible inside higher priced phone (like the image processor) and camera that so far none of the Chinese makers are even close to the calibre.

 

The days of ROM flashing is also getting to an end as Google and other manufactures have introduced A/B partitions and hardware fuse. Not that I dislike flashing LOS or other ROM, I just don't think maintaining kernel, ROM, Magisk is worth my time, and like another poster said, if the phone software is done right, it should not need custom solutions. This is also where Chinese phones are weak at, they just simply don't have any support due to higher cost and competition there. They rather spend the money to sell you a new one than fixing/updating the current working one.

 

I have been using Andorid since Donut, I have been a ROM flashaholic since then and it seems I have stopped doing it since Nexus 5X, I tried to like Chinese phones like Xiaomi, ZTE and LeEco which they last about 9 months because custom ROM is lacking some features (ie Widewine for Netflix), but I ended up picking up the Pixel again. So far none of the Google phone has been disappointing in the software department.

 

We can argue all day on custom ROM and overpriced phones, but at the end of the day. Do you want to spend time tinkering your phone or just want to enjoy it?

 

I also enjoyed tinkering my car in the younger days for extra performance, but now I just buy a higher performing one instead. Same idea.

My take on the rooting and custom rom thing is this:  It wouldn't be necessary if the software on the phone was made correctly in the first place.

 

I'm and Android user and I've rooted and installed custom ROMs in the past for a few different devices that I've used.  Overall, if I'm satisfied with the software that the manufactuer has provided for the phone, I won't bother with rooting or changing the ROM. I don't feel the need to control everything within my phone's software, but whevenever I have gone the custom ROM route, it has always been for what I have seen as glaring errors in software programming or because of a feature of a phone that I consider to be so basic, but I feel that the the manufacturer got it wrong and never bothered to provide any updates.

srlawren
Retired Oracle / Oracle Retraité

The whole rooting and custom ROM thing....  I get the value, I guess.  And I mean, I'm by far not a technophobe... I'm an experienced software developer and love tech in general.  But when you find an OEM ROM like OxygenOS, I just don't see the need to replace it really.  To me, and this is only my personal opinion, it's kind of like the perfect medium between iOS and full custom ROM Android.  It's got the "it just works really well out of the box" aspects of iOS without the walled-garden of Apple's ecosystem and without needing to root and give up some of the niceties like Google Pay and Netflix (of course there are workarounds but as someone mentioned it's a cat and mouse game).  I don't know, maybe I'm crazy.  Or maybe I'm just getting "too old for this sh!t", but that's where my head's at these days.


>>> ALERT: I am not a moderator. For account or activation assistance, please click here.


@stonechucker wrote:

@zhadj030, NFC worked fine on my rooted Nexus 5, running a custom ROM on Marshmallow 6.0.1

 

 


What I meant is that NFC is now mostly used for Google pay which (Google Pay ) does not work with any rooted phone, any other functions for NFC are not affected

@zhadj030, NFC worked fine on my rooted Nexus 5, running a custom ROM on Marshmallow 6.0.1

 

 

killer23d
Great Citizen / Super Citoyen

@drmartin wrote:

@killer23d wrote:

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.


Xiaomi is entering the US market directly, they've already started with some products, phones are coming next! 🙂

 

But if you really want to use them and are unhappy with the OS you can just run with a custom ROM, like LineageOS. 🙂


I am a ROM flasha-holic and I suspect how many of us in here are actually comfortable with getting the BL unlocked then install TWRP and LOS.

 

Until Xiaomi officially comes with the Play Store and is certified by Google and is sold officially in the US, I would not recommend it for normal users (my mother-in-law for example).

 

MIUI is my opinion takes too much inspirations from iOS. I will take the Nokia 6 and my Pixel over any Chinese brands simple because I don't have to flash anything.

 

If price is something you are looking for, getting a Amazon Prime exclusive phone is also excellent value.

Effort
Model Citizen / Citoyen Modèle

Not really, you just need to update regularly to bypass safetynet.

 

I personally don't use googlepay even though my OnePlus 5t fully supports it.


@srlawren wrote:

@szymon247 wrote:

The latest Xiaomi Pocophone is the best value device in the history of Android since the Nexus 7 tablets.


@szymon247 Yes the Pocophone is pretty amazing and offers incredible value, as long as you don't need NFC which it sadly lacks.  I'm sure many people would gladly pay $10-15 more (or whatever it costs to provide NFC) as many of us are becoming addicted to Google Pay.  Ah well, probably not a deal-breaker for everyone but still a fairly strange omission in 2018.

 


NFC will not be a big deal breaker if you love to root you phones as Google pay and other types do not work on rooted phones:(  (unless you go magisk and becomes a cat and mouse game)

srlawren
Retired Oracle / Oracle Retraité

@szymon247 wrote:

The latest Xiaomi Pocophone is the best value device in the history of Android since the Nexus 7 tablets.


@szymon247 Yes the Pocophone is pretty amazing and offers incredible value, as long as you don't need NFC which it sadly lacks.  I'm sure many people would gladly pay $10-15 more (or whatever it costs to provide NFC) as many of us are becoming addicted to Google Pay.  Ah well, probably not a deal-breaker for everyone but still a fairly strange omission in 2018.

 


>>> ALERT: I am not a moderator. For account or activation assistance, please click here.


@bridonca wrote:

I am waiting for a buyer of this tat to come to this forum wondering why is does not work well with Public Mobile!  Half the LTE bands are not even supported!   It is certainly not optimized for Canadian networks!  Stay away, spend your money elsewhere!


And what lte band is missing in the global model that makes it unusable?  Many people pay $1000 for their flagship phone and hang onto it for 4 years to extract fill value and in the meantime, new LTE bands roll out.  What happens then?  The Xiaomi global model typically come with band 4, 5, 7 which covers 95+% of the network.  Some models for the Taiwan market also has band 2.  

 

It is possible that somebody will mistaken global rom with global model and end up with a 3G phone.  Whose fault is that?  Certainly not the oem's fault.

GTB86
Good Citizen / Bon Citoyen

Thanks for your response William!


@killer23d wrote:

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.


I rather get I really paid for then pay for an overpriced 1K smartphones despite the fact that it should only cost half of that price in a perfect world. Chinese phones are making a huge breakthrough in Europe and the rest of the world except North America the only  2 reasons they are not as popular and an option in North America is lack of full bands support and Lobbying.

Regarding Warranties, they are a nightmare no matter the name of the company, (I am not even going to mention Samsung/ LG because of how annoying their warranty departement is) 

About the info being "leaked", it is the same as in the US. You cannot tell me that your info are not with NSA or other agencies just because you have an Apple or a Samsung product. No product is fully secure no matter what.

bridonca
Model Citizen / Citoyen Modèle

I am waiting for a buyer of this tat to come to this forum wondering why is does not work well with Public Mobile!  Half the LTE bands are not even supported!   It is certainly not optimized for Canadian networks!  Stay away, spend your money elsewhere!


@killer23d wrote:

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.


Keep on getting educated by commercials on TV.  Samsung will have you believing the unbelievable.  Think Galaxy note 7.  A warranty doesn't make a good product.  Not having to use the warrant is what we all want.  Over the past few years, I have tried a number of non traditional brands to North Americans such as one plus at time of start up, Oppo, LeEco, and most recently Xiaomi.  I have never been disappointed.  I do my research and don't rely on ads to brainwash.  This phone has great potential because of the OS support from Google.  Don't be so dismissive.

will13am
Oracle
Oracle

@GTB86, I have been shilling Xiaomi phones for the past few months ever since I tried out the Redmi note 5.  Xiaomi sells phones at amazingly low price.  I guess it comes from the fact that their market is primarily their domestic market plus the third world.  These markets are far more price sensitive than North America.  It will be interesting when they officially enter the North American market.  I guess I am being optimistic that they will come here.  They have been selling global versions of some phones through overseas distribution channels, most notably AliExpress.  In fact the Mi A2 is available already through the Xiaomi online store.  The phone that I have on my radar is the Pocophone F1.  They have not released a global edition of that phone yet, hoping they do soon.  The Pocophone F1 is a flagship phone at half price.  By the way, Android one OS is intended for lower end devices.  

 

https://xiaomionline.aliexpress.com/store/2178148

drmartin
Model Citizen / Citoyen Modèle

@killer23d wrote:

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.


Xiaomi is entering the US market directly, they've already started with some products, phones are coming next! 🙂

 

But if you really want to use them and are unhappy with the OS you can just run with a custom ROM, like LineageOS. 🙂

szymon247
Great Citizen / Super Citoyen

Xiaomi isn't in any way inferior to the phones sold in the US/Canada, except the limited support here. It's the Apple/Samsung of China, they are excellent at everything they do.

The latest Xiaomi Pocophone is the best value device in the history of Android since the Nexus 7 tablets. It's a huge thing wherever they're available. I hope they manage to enter Canada soon, they offer really disruptive devices.

killer23d
Great Citizen / Super Citoyen

Like I always tell everyone: you get what you paid for. Chinese phones are designed for specific markets, and XiaoMi does not sell to North America. If you are willing to accept lack of warranty and your info "potentially" intecepted to China, then they are great value.

 

Otherwise, down in the US, there are many options like Nokia 6.1 and Motorola G series which at least you can get some warranty and North America support.

Its recommendation from him.  

GTB86
Good Citizen / Bon Citoyen

I wish I got more than just the potential to save money on a phone plan by posting here..🙄

 

 

bbdata
Model Citizen / Citoyen Modèle

Does sound like a shameless plug.

 

Besides, if a person is considering a Xiaomi Mi. They released the A2 this year. Why consider an older product?

Effort
Model Citizen / Citoyen Modèle

Yeah sounds like an ad and a bad one considering the phone's still on 8.0 and doesn't support treble with Xiaomi having no intention of supporting past what it currently has.

Is this a real question, or is it advertisement for the third-party amazon seller?

Need Help? Let's chat.