If you change the plan immediately it will make that date the new renewal and charge you for the new plan. You should have selected change at renewal then the plan would have changed at your next renewal date instead of charging you again.
You could try contacting the Mods to see if they can help you out.
How can you get help with your account, activation, or service?
In your message please include:
Don't know your pin?--provide any 3 of the following:
How long until they reply?:
How can I view my private messages between myself and a Community Moderator