topic Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers in Get Support

Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Jlund — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 17:58:48 GMT

I initially thought public and freedom were in a price war. Not that I'm a fan of freedom but they are winning decisively. Here is there offer today. C'mon public, you can match this.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Andy85 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:08:00 GMT

@Jlund It's a great deal, not gonna lie. The deal is only valid for a 24 month period before one would lose the $5/month credit though. That said, there is so little cellphone service provider competition that it wouldn't be wise for these big monopolies to drive down the price of the market. If these large companies stay the course, they will continue to shovel in millions and billions in profits which essentially ensures that they all win. None of them will win if they try to undercut each other's prices. That's the reality of what it's like when certain markets are controlled by monopolies.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

hTideGnow — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:05:02 GMT

hi @Jlund Freedom is slightly different. They have slightly crazier deals sometimes but their network is not as solid as PM's PM will try to follow some of their plans but not all, that's normal

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

dwh1 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:08:08 GMT

Can't disagree it'd be nice to see PM be at the $34/40 level, at least for a 4G plan. I'd still stay here since the network is better and I'm not a fan of plans with a built-in price increase (even if it is 2 years out).

But yeah - c'mon, PM!

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Sansan — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:08:13 GMT

That is a good offer.

I was on koodo website they have similar offer as posted, plus i found this.

So there are many options out there. Just have to shop around.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Chipster — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:09:00 GMT

Carrier	Physical Coverage	Population Covered
Bell	28.8%	99%
TELUS	28.8%	99%
Rogers	19.9%	97%
Freedom	.066%	33%

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

golfball — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:17:59 GMT

Yep. PM never offered me the $25 5GB plan as an upgrade from my $15 plan. I was able to grab a $20 4G plan elsewhere and have it on an eSIM for additional data while figuring out which to keep. They are leaving money on the table by not being competitive.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Andy85 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:16:15 GMT

One thing I'll say is that for the first Black Friday in almost forever, it's nice to see companies make a big spash in the amount of data they are offering their clients. I hope that this isn't just a 1 time offer. Hopefully this sets the bar for more attractive plans for a year round basis.

Additionally, I hope that the CRTC revisits their Low-cost wireless service plan criteria. The $15 dollar plan barely meets the needs of the average Canadian. Times have changed very rapidly and almost everything takes place online. 250MB is barely enough if someone is in a dire emergency.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

golfball — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:30:00 GMT

Yes, these are all very outdated. $35 minimum just for picture messaging? Texting overage fees and long distance charges within Canada? None of that is very relevant today.

I used to rarely go over my 250mb but now it seems I'm dipping into the holiday add-ons every month.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Andy85 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 18:49:39 GMT

@golfball Exactly! Media sources have changed that are downloaded have changed considerably from the time of that CRTC regulation. I am unsure if the CRTC have any plans to revisit their guidelines.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

dwh1 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 19:19:42 GMT

For anyone following this thread: PM just added a matching $34 for 40GB + unlimited plan, matching the Freedom price. I'd also note that the PM price won't go up in two years, plus there are whatever points/rebates you have.

Re: Why isn't Public keeping up with Freedom's offers

Andy85 — Fri, 24 Nov 2023 19:24:16 GMT

@dwh1 wrote:
For anyone following this thread: PM just added a matching $34 for 40GB + unlimited plan, matching the Freedom price. I'd also note that the PM price won't go up in two years, plus there are whatever points/rebates you have.

Sure looks like it!