topic Re: marking yourself as the solution? in Get Support

marking yourself as the solution?

torontokris — Wed, 05 Jan 2022 09:56:43 GMT

I noticed that a recent post, the poster marked themselves as a solution... wait you can still do that? Could lead to people making up stupid threads like 1+1 equals? or how do I turn my phone on? ... then reply and mark as "solution". Gaining them solution points

Although I guess the thought is if the original poster found a solution (that fixed the problem) that they post and mark it as the solution

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

mtfolks — Sun, 17 Jun 2018 15:58:18 GMT

I’ve brought this up in the past as I have seen it abused before but luckily it does not seem to happen often. If you see abuse happening let a mod or oracle know.

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

will13am — Sun, 17 Jun 2018 16:54:19 GMT

I have seen this in the past. It's not that prevalent. Sometimes people do figure out the solution to their problem and mark the thread as solved. Some appear to have nefarious intentions. The embarrassed of being called out for questionable intent is sufficient deterrent.

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

NDesai — Sun, 17 Jun 2018 18:16:37 GMT

As mentioned above, sometimes users figure out the problem themselves and post the solution in case other run into the same problem. I think that is ok and should be allowed. What should not be allowed is when the topic doesn't contain a valid problem. In this case, a random post with some helpful comment should not be accepted as a solution.

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

jp2 — Sun, 17 Jun 2018 19:22:15 GMT

Couldn't PM just change the formula so if the OP marks them self as the solution it doesn't count towards rewards? My thinking is even if the OP actually solves there own issue they aren't helping others so it shouldn't count for rewards

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

ShawnC13 — Sun, 17 Jun 2018 19:32:46 GMT

@jp2 wrote:
Couldn't PM just change the formula so if the OP marks them self as the solution it doesn't count towards rewards? My thinking is even if the OP actually solves there own issue they aren't helping others so it shouldn't count for rewards

If the OP dues solve the issue and posts it could help others that have the same issue in the future though. We have many people that watch for this and it is very obvious to catch. I am not worried as I am sure if someone was doing this to move up in rewards they would be caught before they got very far

Re: marking yourself as the solution?

NDesai — Mon, 18 Jun 2018 00:22:52 GMT

@ShawnC13 wrote:
@jp2 wrote:
Couldn't PM just change the formula so if the OP marks them self as the solution it doesn't count towards rewards? My thinking is even if the OP actually solves there own issue they aren't helping others so it shouldn't count for rewards
If the OP dues solve the issue and posts it could help others that have the same issue in the future though. We have many people that watch for this and it is very obvious to catch. I am not worried as I am sure if someone was doing this to move up in rewards they would be caught before they got very far

Some being smart by having multiple accounts. They post a simple problem and reply a solution from other accounts. In this case, it's not so easy to catch them. But there are other ways to catch that i will not go into the details just because.